No, I didn't make this one myself. Rather, this post will treat my adventures as a NYC ex-pat in search of my native staple. I've now been living away from New York City for five and a half years, and never have I found pizza as good as the pizza with which I grew up. When I was 11 years old, I went to Italy with my parents for the first time and ate margherita pizza almost everywhere we went. I believe wholeheartedly that the test of a pizzeria's quality is in its plain, cheese, margherita pizza. Toppings, for the most part, are a distraction from the potentially perfect equilibrium of dough, sauce and cheese. To be fair, I have certainly indulged in many a slice of pepperoni in New York, and occasionally a slice of olive pizza. Topping are an enhancement only when the pizza is good, otherwise, they are there simply to cloak the poor quality of the core ingredients.
Montreal for the most part has horrible pizza. Many of their toppings go underneath the cheese, including the "pepperoni", which is really more like badly spiced pork salami. The one thing that brings to many Montrealers to consume pizza with any frequency is that it is damn cheap! There are many 99¢ options for the drunk wandering out of a club at 3 o'clock in the morning. I consistently ate pizza from two different locations in Montreal. Pizza 1+1, which was not very good pizza, but somehow they were the only ones in the city able to procure real pepperoni, and they managed to put it on top of the cheese. Otherwise, for a proper margherita, I would order form the Italian restaurant Pino, a plain pie that while delicious was rather expensive.
Jerusalem, surprisingly, is home to the best New York impostor I have yet found across the Atlantic. "Big Apple Pizza" has found some formula to reproduce a taste that I've only had prior in NY, despite the fact that their slices are about half the size, and the crust is slightly reminiscent of cardboard. Otherwise, the pizza there tends to be awful. For whatever reason, many Israeli establishments use the same dough for pita as they do for pizza. Despite the fact that they are near homophones, I vehemently insist that no pizza dough ought to be like a pita. The fact that they used pita dough produced the very strange result that the already cooked dough would sometimes split, like a pita. I suppose if you don't like too much dough, then this offers your an opportunity to take off half of it, otherwise, it's just strange.
I expected to find good pizza in the south of France. I was studying at culinary school in a place that was more or less half way between Italy and Spain. Alas, the french have no appreciation for the extent to which Mozzarella is essential to good pizza! I ate a few pizzas in France, always wondering why the taste was so strange, before I decided to ask the proprietors of several pizzerias what cheese they employed. "Ici on n'a que de l'emmental!" I would hear at most places. Finally, I found a man with what I identified as a thick Italian accent. In fact, he simply had a very thick southern French accent, which to the unaccustomed could easily be mistaken as Italian. Nevertheless, this pseudo-Italian, had Mozzarella at his pizzeria! But just my luck, the pizzeria closed 2 weeks after I discovered it in October, and would not open again until May when the tourists began to return.
Finally, I have come to Tel Aviv. The day I arrived I began to search for all sorts of gastronomic fair. It took me about a week to find all the Asian stores, a month to find a good butcher, and 6 to find the pizzeria that has taken my money several times a week ever since. I tried all sorts of pizza, however, before finding succulence. I'm a pizza addict, what can I do? The first pizza that came highly recommended was a place called Tony Vespa. Tony Vespa has several locations in Tel Aviv, and they make their pizza sort of in the style of the Italian "a taglio"--that is to say a large rectangular pie that of which a piece is cut to your preference, then priced according to weight. They charge and absurd amount of money: 88 shekels a kilo! That's over 20 dollars a kilo, for bloody pizza. Further more, they don't make pizza properly. The bake a large rectangular focaccia, that is dressed with sauce and cheese and returned to the oven only after the dough has fully become bread. I might as well make pizza toast at home with cheese and bread I buy at the shuk and a sauce I can myself.
Secondly, there was "Agvania", which means "Tomato" in Hebrew. Agvania has very tasty pizza, but it too is expensive. The crust is impossibly thin, something achieved only with the aid of electric rolling machine through which they put each piece of dough twice. The result, is that the exterior of the pie is simply a cracker by the time it leave the oven. They have become quite popular in Tel Aviv, however, dude to their excellent sauce. I find the plain simply not filling enough at Agvania. It's a kosher establishment, which means no meat present, so I usually get a slice of tomato, garlic and basil. It's like deconstructing the sauce and adding it at a topping.
Over the summer I frequented another pizzeria relatively often. It was recommended to me by a friend and it was damn hard to find. It's off of Nahalat Binyamin, which is a pedestrian street. The pizzeria is accessed through a narrow corridor beyond a nondescript blue gate, whose existence I would never have noticed if not for the advice of my friend. The place is called "Pijama" and is entirely by one man who owns the building and lives above the pizzeria. It is only open from 7pm-midnight, except for Tuesdays and Fridays when they open for lunch with the hope of attracting those visiting the Nahalat Binyamin crafts' market that occurs on those days. The pizza here is pretty damn good, and had I not discovered my favourite pizza in TA, I might still eat there sometimes. The pizzas there come in 3 sizes: personal, double, and family. The dough and sauce are excellent, but the cheese is "yellow cheese", which is not actually yellow in colour, and is a cheap substitute for mozzarella. Frankly, as good as it was and as much as I liked the feeling of being privy to well kept secret, I finally have found a pizzeria with which I can find almost no complaints.
HaPizza, on Bugrashov. Aptly named "The Pizza" in Hebrew, this place has captured the attentions of my palate with great frequency. This is not NY style pizza by any means - there are only two options, personal pie and half a personal pie, and the pizza is cooked in a brick oven. It is by all means an Italian style pizzeria. It's not terribly cheap, a personal pie costs about 9 dollars and is the equivalent in weight of 2 NYC slices, but it's damn good! The staff there are at this point familiar with my face, and one a woman asked me, "why do you always buy the margherita?" I gave her my explanation about an equilibrium, and rather than taking the highly bestowed compliment, she tried to get me to add toppings to make my pizza a little more expensive. Typical. HaPizza also offers a white pie, made with fresh mozzarella and topped with a chiffonade of basil which is also excellent. Everything is tasty and the right texture. There is a perfect balance of dough-sauce-cheese, and the dough, while thin, manages to retain a more bready quality in it's exterior than the cracker-like substance found at Agvania.
None of this is to say that i do not still long for a slice of NYC pizza (I won't begin to name specific pizzerias for fear of a war of words with other New Yorkers who may be reading this). But my addiction is better sated than a smoker on the patch.
If ever any of you are in Tel Aviv, I most highly recommend a stop at HaPizza on the corner of Pinsker and Bugrashov.
Recent Comments